Welcome to Witherby Where Speakeasy Secrets Meet Signature Sips

From Speakeasy Secrets to Signature Sips: Welcome to Witherby

A Historic Haunt with a Modern Menu and a Whole Lot of Charm. There’s something magical happening behind the original 1886 bar at The Beau Hotel. It starts with a flicker of candlelight bouncing off exposed brick and ends with a cinnamon-sage lasagna that tastes like your great-grandmother just came back from Tuscany. Welcome to Witherby, the newly rebranded restaurant at The Beau, where California Modern cuisine mingles with rich San Diego history, ghost stories, and more than a few expertly crafted cocktails.

Why the Name Witherby?

Formerly known as The Bar at The Beau, the transformation to Witherby isn’t just cosmetic. The new name is a nod to Henry Witherby, the very first tenant in the original Belmont building that still forms the bones of this lovingly restored Gaslamp property. But this isn’t a throwback for throwback’s sake—Witherby signals a new chapter of elevated dining, rich storytelling, and a full-on embrace of what makes The Beau experience unforgettable.

Chef Robin James, whose California Modern menu inspired the shift, is as much a storyteller as he is a chef. From the Faroe Islands Salmon nestled in carrot-coconut purée to the duck pot pie that somehow feels like both a weeknight comfort meal and a Michelin-star dream, the dishes here carry heart, history, and serious culinary chops.

Not Your Average Hotel Bar

Let’s be clear: this isn’t just a place to grab a nightcap before heading upstairs. Witherby stands on its own—physically, philosophically, and gastronomically. The ambiance is elegant but not stiff, stylish without being try-hard. Everything down to the toothpick is intentional. (In fact, there are no toothpicks—only sleek metal skewers in your cocktails, because plastic is so last century.)

On our recent visit, we sat in plush seating so luxurious it could have doubled as a therapy couch. The vibe was cozy but refined—like your favorite cashmere sweater after it’s been to finishing school. Every corner tells a story: historic books line the walls, a gleaming crest catches the light, and you half-expect a 1920s jazz band to start playing out of nowhere.

Meet the Cast

A good restaurant has great food. A great restaurant has great people. And Witherby is brimming with them.

Valentine, the effervescent manager and San Diego native, greeted us with a sparkle in her eye and the kind of warm hospitality that can’t be faked. She’s the kind of person who makes you feel like you’ve just returned home—even if it’s your first visit.

Then there’s Brandi, the Food & Beverage Manager, who practically glows with enthusiasm when describing the signature cocktails or the backstory of Chef Robin’s recipes. Behind the bar is Luis, shaking up an 1886 Old Fashioned like he invented the drink himself (and who’s to say he didn’t?).

And of course, there’s Kathy, the visionary owner of The Beau Hotel. She bought the building when she was just 25 years old—because when you fall in love with something, you don’t wait. Her fingerprints are all over the experience, from the curated antiques to the hidden “smugglers alley” that nods to the building’s Prohibition-era past.

Culinary Roots with a Side of Sass

Chef Robin’s menu isn’t just about flavor—it’s about feeling. His lasagna, for example, evokes the comforting chaos of Thanksgiving, thanks to a spiced sauce passed down from his great-great-grandfather. It’s hearty, nostalgic, and just complex enough to surprise you.

Other standouts include the Kanpachi Crudo with white corn salad, which balances sweet, tart, and umami like a culinary tightrope act. The Braised Pork Shank is the kind of dish you make a reservation for on a Monday just to make the week bearable. And don’t skip the Stonefruit and Burrata Salad, which tastes like California sunshine on a plate.

Breakfast, sunset cocktails, or full-blown dinner—Witherby serves it all, and does so with a wink and a nod to the past while keeping both feet (and a cutting-edge mandoline) firmly in the present.

Spirits of the Past

And speaking of nods to the past, let’s talk about the ghost. Yes, really.

Rumor has it there’s a specter who calls The Beau home. Nobody’s quite sure if it’s a flapper girl who missed last call or a former barkeep with unfinished cocktail business—but guests (and even staff) have reported the occasional unexplainable flicker of light or waft of perfume. Don’t worry—it’s a friendly ghost. Probably just upset you didn’t order dessert.

The entire space feels alive with history, not haunted by it. Original bricks hauled over from a Coronado foundry anchor the space in something solid and real. Smugglers Alley, a narrow hallway leftover from Prohibition days, gives the restaurant a speakeasy edge without feeling gimmicky. Every detail, from the custom lighting to the vintage crest, has been considered, curated, and, in many cases, lovingly restored.

A Toast to Timelessness

There’s something wildly refreshing about a place that isn’t trying to chase trends. Witherby doesn’t need to. It’s rooted in the kind of authenticity you can’t fake—from its architecture to its attitude. It’s the kind of place you discover once and then keep returning to, not because it’s on every influencer’s list, but because it makes you feel like a character in your own story.

And when you do return, order the Beau Bloom. Created by bartender Luis, it’s perfection in a coupe glass—a floral gin sour made with house-made lavender syrup, lemon, and egg white, served in delicate crystal. The soft purple hue is as inviting as its silky, citrus-laced flavor. It’s smooth, aromatic, and balanced—elegant yet playful. The Beau Bloom is everything a signature cocktail should be: original, delicious, and just unforgettable enough that you’ll come back for it.

You can sip that while catching up with friends, celebrating an anniversary, or just staring meaningfully into your drink while pretending to write a novel. The possibilities are endless. And thanks to the team behind it, the experience is always warm, grounded, and just the right amount of extraordinary.

Final Thoughts

Witherby is more than a name change. It’s a bold move forward that keeps its heart in the past. The Beau Hotel has always felt like a secret worth sharing—Witherby is simply the newest chapter in a story that keeps getting better with every pour, every plate, and every passing guest.

So come for the food. Stay for the ghosts. Leave with a new favorite memory.

For reservations, menus, and more information, visit www.thebeauhotel.com/bar and follow @TheBeauHotel and @WitherbySD on Instagram.

Here are some other articles related to your search:

• Best Speakeasy Bars in San Diego

• Welcome to Witherby Where Speakeasy Secrets Meet Signature Sips

• Cocktails and All That Jazz at the Bassmnt Nightclub