Au Pair Matching Mistakes Families Often Make (And How to Avoid Them)

Choosing to host an au pair is an exciting decision that can bring cultural exchange, childcare support, and lasting relationships into your home. 

However, the process of selecting the right au pair isn’t always straightforward. Many families, especially those new to the concept, make avoidable mistakes during the matching phase. 

These missteps can lead to misunderstandings, mismatched expectations, or even a failed placement. Here are some of the most common au pair matching mistakes families make—and how to sidestep them for a smoother experience.

1. Focusing Only on the Resume

It’s easy to get caught up in a candidate’s experience, certifications, or number of years working with children. 

While qualifications do matter, they don’t tell the whole story. Many families assume that someone who’s worked in childcare for years will automatically be a great fit, but personality, communication style, and values are equally—if not more—important.

Avoid this mistake by taking time to get to know the person behind the resume. Schedule video calls, ask open-ended questions, and observe how they engage with you and your children. Sometimes a less-experienced candidate may turn out to be the better cultural and emotional match for your family.

2. Overlooking Cultural Compatibility

The whole point of the au pair experience is cultural exchange, but differences in customs, language, and daily routines can cause tension if not acknowledged early on. Families sometimes expect the au pair to immediately adjust to their lifestyle without realizing that culture shock is real—and it goes both ways.

To avoid this, talk openly about your family’s norms and expectations during the interview stage. Be curious about your candidate’s culture too. What’s a normal daily routine in their country? How do they typically approach discipline, meals, or downtime? Clear, honest conversations early on will help you identify whether your lifestyles can mesh well, and show your prospective au pair that you're equally invested in their comfort and integration.

3. Ignoring the Structure of the Au Pair Program

One of the biggest mistakes families make is misunderstanding the nature of the au pair program itself. This isn't a nanny service—it's a cultural exchange regulated by specific rules, including limits on working hours, responsibilities, and required time off. 

Some families enter the program with unrealistic expectations, hoping to get full-time childcare, housekeeping, or irregular hours covered. This leads to frustration for both sides.

Before matching, thoroughly research the rules and expectations set by your au pair agency and the government. Understand what your responsibilities are as a host family—providing room and board, paying a stipend, ensuring access to education—and what your au pair is and isn’t expected to do. Clear communication and a shared understanding of the program’s structure will help set boundaries and prevent misunderstandings.

4. Rushing the Process

In a time crunch—perhaps a last-minute cancellation or an urgent need for childcare—families sometimes rush into a match without doing their due diligence. A quick match may seem convenient, but skipping the crucial steps of interviewing, discussing expectations, and checking references can lead to disappointment or conflict down the line.

Take your time. Use the interview process not just to gather facts but to build a rapport. Try to speak with more than one candidate and compare your impressions. Also, talk to previous host families if possible. Remember, this person will live with you and care for your children—this isn’t a decision to be made lightly or hastily.

By avoiding these common mistakes, your family can set the foundation for a successful and rewarding au pair experience. The key lies in being intentional: communicate openly, manage expectations, and invest time in the matching process. 

When done right, bringing an au pair into your home can be one of the most enriching decisions you make—for your children, your family, and the au pair themselves.

Related Articles:

• Providing Hospice Care For Families As Well As Patients
• Your Guide to Caring for an Elderly Family Member